Article -

The Binding of Isaac: Piety and Protest


Authors: Jo Milgrom and Yoel Duman







The Binding of Isaac: Piety and Protest

Some time ago at the beginning of Jewish history an inscrutable God, without explanation, orders his favorite founder, Abraham, to sacrifice his beloved son. Without questioning, the old man hastens to the task. Aware or unaware, the son participates in the preparations. In the end God changes his mind, but the father and son do not return home together.
You can`t be neutral. Either you marvel at the man`s faith and courage or you revile his madness. In fact, many critical issues in Judaism inform this foundation tale, even prefiguring the character of its daughter religions, Christianity and Islam:
The bewilderment/awe at being challenged by God: Is it God? Why me? How do I respond?
Sacred geography: the internal/spiritual and external/physical journey

Is human aggression hard-wired?
Love and tension in the family

The silencing of the woman
Is there a conflict between faith and morality?

Both piety and protest emerge from these issues: the acceptance of the biblical account as normative and right, and the critique of foundational sancta.
The biblical account already contains the seeds of its own deconstruction. Isaac`s question “where is the lamb?” expresses either total naivete or covert suspicion. Already in the earliest Midrashim, Isaac cries out, torn between faith and fear, imploring Abraham to bind him well lest his instinctive resistance blemish the sacrifice. As we shall see, by the Renaissance these reservations grow to outright confrontation and in modern times to rejection. We will hear both voices, read both texts, scrutinize the conflicting images, and then…








The earliest substantial Jewish art

Prior to the 1930`s, most scholars were convinced that ancient Jewry produced no art. As a result, the discovery in 1932 of the biblical wall-paintings decorating the third century synagogue of Dura Europos, Syria stunned the academic world.
In these earliest extant examples of Jewish art (antedating comparable Christian art by two centuries) the community expresses its acceptance of pious rabbinic midrashim.

Center stage above the Torah ark, a naively drawn Abraham stands firm before the altar, knife raised, his back to the viewer.

Dura Europos Synagogue, Akedah (detail)

Dura Europos Synagogue,
Akedah (detail)

The saving ram is tethered behind Abraham awaiting its theological moment. Tiny Isaac is impaled upon a monumental altar (see the Midrash in Targum Yonatan, below). He too looks away from us, as does Sarah (rarely represented in akedah scenes) in the doorway of her tent, the highest and most distant point of the scene. They are all focused on the hand of God, “the Place from afar” at Moriah (v.3), identified in late biblical times as the site of the once and forever restored Temple of Jerusalem. 170 years after its destruction, the Temple and its implements are visually restored at the center and left of this scene, together with the akedah, the symbols of diaspora hope for national and religious restoration.

Dura Europos Synagogue, Akedah, 244

Dura Europos Synagogue, Akedah, 244

Just three years prior to the discovery of Dura, a stunning mosaic floor of a 6th century synagogue had been uncovered at Kibbutz Bet Alpha., the earliest akedah to be found in Israel. The naive style of the mosaic displays Jewish, pagan and possibly Christian elements.

Bet Alpha Synagogue, Entire Floor

Bet Alpha Synagogue, Entire Floor

Bet Alpha Synagogue, Akedah, 6th century

Bet Alpha Synagogue, Akedah, 6th century

 

On entering the synagogue, the worshiper first encountered the akedah, a focal narrative of Jewish tradition. The worshiper next saw a zodiac, centered on the sun god Helios and his chariot. Is this a synagogue? It is likely that these pagan symbols were interpreted as representing the ritual calendar of the congregation – but, it is also evidence of a Judaism culturally alive to the imagery of the Greco-Roman Byzantine heritage. Finally, in the third section, closest to the holy ark, the worshiper saw (as in Dura) the doors, menorah and ritual tools of the restored Temple.

 

The playful color patterns and paper-doll character of the figures belie the theological intensity of the akedah scene.
The two servants stand at the left, together with the ass (v. 5). At the center point, the ram hangs from a bush, rather than being caught in the thicket, as recounted in the Bible (v. 13). Above, a haloed hand of the angel “calls out”: Do not raise [your hand] (v. 11 – 12). On the right, the child Isaac is held aloft between Abraham and the burning altar (v. 10). The artists altered the sequence of the story by placing the ram at center stage. Thus the mosaic seems to focus on God`s compassionate substitution of Isaac by the ram, rather than on Abraham`s extraordinary act of faith. It has been suggested that the hanging ram is based on Christian iconography, connecting Isaac, the ram and Jesus as parallel sacrifices. But just as in the use of the pagan zodiac, the borrowing of this model does not imply a heterodox interpretation, but rather cultural contact.

 

Contemporaneous with the Bet Alpha mosaic, the rabbinic community in Palestine produced an Aramaic paraphrase of the Torah called Targum Yonatan (Pseudo Jonathan). The writing of this document began in pre-Christian times and was completed shortly after Islam came on the scene. I wish I could have known that guy. Over 600 years of imaginative rewriting of the bible. The text looks like a fabric into which daring colors have been interwoven. The daring color is the paraphrase, the words of the Targum stuck in between the words of the Bible to expand and explain. These insertions are not questions; they are the answers. We have to ask the questions that provoked those answers. Those answers constitute the rabbinic theology in the early Christian centuries. They reveal how Jews of those early centuries dealt with the harrowing tale of the akedah. They were not subversives. They were its greatest supporters. They even got God off the hook for giving those awful orders.

 

The following text shows how the colorful weaving was done. Upper case letters are the biblical text. Lower case, the targum insertion.

 

1. AND IT WAS AFTER THESE THINGS when Isaac and Ishmael argued, that Ishmael said, It is right that I should inherit Father since I am his first born. But Isaac said, It is right for me to inherit Father because I am the son of Sarah his wife and you are the son of Hagar my mother`s maid. Ishmael answered saying, I am more worthy than you because I was circumcised at age 13; if it had been my will to hold back I would not have risked my life to be circumcised. But you were circumcised when you were 8 days old; had you known what it was all about you would not have risked your life. Isaac replied, Today I am 37 years old. If the Holy One, blessed be He, were to ask for all my limbs I would not hold back. Immediately these words were heard before the Lord of the universe and immediately the word of THE LORD TESTED ABRAHAM AND SAID TO HIM, ABRAHAM!

 

This text answers the question “Why did God test Abraham?” and concludes with a tale of sibling rivalry. In other words, it wasn`t God`s idea, it was those quarreling kids that forced the test. Targum Yonatan takes God off the hook.








Two opposing views

We now jump ahead several centuries, to what is loosely called “the Middle Ages” and go from the Jewish context of Bet Alpha and Dura to the Christian sphere.

In this milieu too, the akedah appears frequently in the works of medieval Christian artists, who understood the near sacrifice of Isaac as a prefiguring of Jesus` crucifixion and its physical context is the Church and the Church service.


Chartres Cathedral, Sacrifice of Abraham, 1194-1250

Chartres Cathedral, Sacrifice of Abraham
1194-1250

A parade example of the Christian reading of the akedah can be found in the north transept of the gothic Cathedral of Chartres. Here, Abraham and Isaac stand as one column, their feet on the ram. Their parallel faces look upward serenely, toward the angel hovering over the adjacent figure of Melchizedek. Abraham caresses Isaac`s face. Despite the fact that Abraham`s right hand grips the sacrificial knife, there is an air of calm and faith, in which Abraham and Isaac are completely one. Isaac`s crossed hands and feet identify him as a christophorous (Christ-like) figure.
Fifty years earlier, in the Romanesque church at Souillac, a surprisingly different approach to the akedah is taken. In 1939, world-renowned art historian Meyer Schapiro argued that the sculptures in this 12th century church reveal reservations about church doctrine regarding submission and dominance.
“It should be observed … that the theme of Abraham and Isaac, which is not only a symbol of salvation and of the Crucifixion but also…of submission to authority… is parodied on the opposite side of the trumeau by images of conflict between a youth and an old man, wrestling pairs who resemble Abraham and Isaac.”


Souillac Cathedral, Trumeau (left), Sacrifice of Abraham

Souillac Cathedral, Trumeau (left)
Sacrifice of Abraham

Souillac Cathedral, Trumeau (right), Wrestling figures

Souillac Cathedral, Trumeau (right)
Wrestling figures

Thus in Souillac we have an ambivalent presentation of the akedah: on the one hand, Abraham and Isaac submit, with bowed heads, to the will of God; on the other hand, their piety is undermined by the juxtaposition with images of human strife and the questioning of divine authority.








Donatello and Chartres – suffering vs. piety


Donatello, Sacrifice of Abraham, ca. 1418

Donatello, Sacrifice of Abraham
ca. 1418

Chartres, Akedah

Chartres, Akedah

If we were to write a legend under the Chartres akedah, it might be “And the two of them went together” (vv. 6, 8). Donatello`s portrayal of the akedah from 1418, while preserving the columnar structure of Chartres, might be asking: Did the two really go together? While in Chartres, Abraham and Isaac are harmoniously parallel, Donatello`s figures, distorted in expression and proportion, almost ugly, strain in opposite directions. Note particularly the shoulders of father and son. This akedah connotes suffering rather than piety.
A little known midrash, apparently written in 16th century Italy seems to reflect reservations similar to those of Donatello about the akedah:
At that moment [that Abraham informed him that he was the sacrifice], Isaac acquiesced with his mouth, but in his heart he said, “Who will save me from my father? I have no help other than God, as it is said `My help is from the Lord`”.









The view from Mecca

Islam follows in the path of Judaism and Christianity, also cherishing the figure of Abraham, as the friend of God. However, the bound son is not identified in the Koran`s account of the akedah. But by the time the first paintings of the akedah appear in Islamic art in the late Middle Ages, normative Islam had designated Ishmael as the offering.

 

Riza-i Abbasi, Abraham’s Sacrifice, Qisas al-Anbiyya, 16<sup>th</sup> cent.

Riza-i Abbasi, Abraham’s Sacrifice, Qisas al-Anbiyya, 16th cent.

 

In this 16th century Persian manuscript of the Tales of the Prophets, an invisible X intersects the landscape. A single figure occupies each quadrant. One diagonal, following the mountain, separates heaven and earth. The other, connects the heavenly pair (angel/ram) to the earthly pair Abraham/Ishmael). Ishmael enraptured crouches unbound and compliant. Abraham presses on the youth, one hand pulling his son`s hair and the other holding the knife to his own breast, as if the patriarch would sooner kill himself. Abraham is torn between love of his son and the divine command. The lines of the X meet at the juncture of heaven and earth anticipating what must or must not happen.








An outcry

 

Caravaggio, The Sacrifice of Isaac, 1601-02

Caravaggio, The Sacrifice of Isaac, 1601-02

 

Our first glance at Caravaggio`s painting focuses on the horror in Isaac`s face; this is no devout illustration of patriarchal piety, but what Phyllis Trible calls a “text of terror”. Two parallel diagonals of light lead us from the face of Isaac, to the angel, to Abraham and to the ram. Despite these physical connections, the relationships are disconnected: the angel points approximately but not directly at the ram; Abraham looks approximately but not directly at the angel; Isaac approximately faces the viewer; only the ram looks directly at Abraham and the angel while nuzzling up to Isaac. The avoidance of eye contact is Caravaggio`s way of expressing the surreal madness of the scene.








3 Rembrandts

Although no contact can be demonstrated between Caravaggio and Rembrandt, they are often linked as the masters of Baroque use of light, shadow and drama. Rembrandt treated many Jewish and biblical themes, including repeatedly the akedah.
Here we will examine three of these treatments, spanning 30 years of the artist`s tumultuous life.

 

Rembrandt, Abraham`s Sacrifice, 1635

The oil painting above, from 1635, was produced during the period of Rembrandt`s greatest popularity as a portrait artist, a popularity that diminished as the artist became less flattering and more honest in his portrayal of his subjects. The diagonal structure of the picture and the use of light are dramatic techniques that propel the viewer between two focal points: Isaac`s body and Abraham`s face. Light on the hands of Abraham and the angel emphasizes the agitated moment. Isaac`s exposed chest radiates light and vulnerability. Abraham, in a state of paralyzed shock and sadness,

 

 

is so intent on doing God`s command that the angel must call to him twice before he drops the knife (compare Caravaggio`s Abraham).
During the next five years of Rembrandt`s life, Saskia, his wife, gave birth to four children, who died at birth; she herself died when the fifth child, Titus (who survived) was born; Rembrandt`s later akedot took on a different pathos;

 

 

Rembrandt, Abraham and Isaac, 1645

 

In the 1645 etching, father and son have arrived at Moriah; Isaac sets down the wood and asks his only question “Father, here is the fire and the wood, but where is the lamb for the offering?” (Genesis 22:7). Abraham`s right hand holds his heart; the index finger of his left hand lies at the center of the line between his eyes and Isaac`s as he answers ambiguously “God will see to the lamb for the offering, my son” (v. 8). Does Isaac know more? Stunned by this answer, his eyes are dark holes; he stands at the edge of a precipice, dark lines swirling above and behind his head.

 

Rembrandt, Abraham`s Sacrifice, 1655

 

Finally, in the 1655 etching, we return to the altar scene. The angel, Abraham and Isaac form a single figure in embrace; diagonal lines from the right bring divine light to Abraham`s left hand, which holds the knife. Now it is Abraham`s eyes that are black holes. The drama of 1635 has become profound pathos of 1655. The artist is unwilling to let it happen, so he undermines the scene. On the one hand the diagonal of divine light can only mean blessing; on the other, Abraham becomes left-handed, awkwardly distancing the knife from Isaac. Kierkegaard writes “Abraham knew joy no longer”.








Jews and the Akedah on the Threshold of Modern Times

We now return to the realm of Jewish art, after a long pause. Contemporaneously with the careers of Caravaggio and Rembrandt, Italian Jews produced a variety of printed Hebrew books, including the Venice Haggadah of 1609.


Venice Haggadah, Akedah, 1609

Venice Haggadah, Akedah, 1609

This akedah (on the right) contains several elements of Christian iconography, including Isaac`s crossed hands, Abraham`s sword and the corporeal angel. The use of non-Jewish iconography is not at all unusual and may be found in a variety of Hebrew illuminated manuscripts, in all parts of Europe, throughout the Middle Ages. In our picture from the Venice Haggadah smoke rising from a fire-pot divides the picture in two. The scene on the left is variously interpreted as: 1) contemporary Jews celebrating Passover or 2) the elderly Isaac with the studious Jacob, Esau the delinquent hunter and the children of Israel in Egypt; thus, it is either an illustration of the magid (narration) or an actualization of the akedah. Strangely enough, the akedah is never actually mentioned in the text of the haggadah; its placement here, accompanying the retelling of Israel`s history and the blessing of God`s steadfastness, is evidence that the akedah was understood as the quintessential symbol of God`s protection.

The connection of the akedah with Rosh Hashanah derives from the motif of judgment and mercy and is linked to the symbol of the shofar. The less well-known connection with Passover derives from an association with the paschal sacrifice, which faded after the destruction of the temple.

A century later, God`s antithetical qualities are daringly embroidered on a Torah curtain from southern Germany, as the compassionate angel emerges from a cloud suggestive of the opposite: the face of the angry God.


Torah Covering, Germany, 1747

Torah Covering, Germany, 1747

The saving ram is slipping away, across the well-defined borders of the curtain, leaving the hapless Isaac to the “mercy” of midat hadin (the quality of harsh judgment).

Up to now, we have presented artworks focused in the main on the climactic moment at the altar. In the early 20th century painting below, Moshe Mizrahi fills out the laconic biblical text with four midrashic tableaux reflecting major themes in the development of literary Midrash, within a frame of majestic columns and traditional images of Jerusalem.


Moshe Shah Mizrahi, Akedat Yitzhak, c. 1920

Moshe Shah Mizrahi, Akedat Yitzhak, c. 1920

In the uppermost panel, Sarah, strangely absent from the biblical narrative, is manipulated by Abraham into letting Isaac depart for “graduate” Torah studies.

Above the trio is the text of their discussion, a quote from the liturgical poem עֵת שַׁעֲרֵי רָצוֹן לְהִפָּתֵחַNow is the time for the gates of favor to open“, sung at the climax of the Rosh Hashana service. “But not too far,” Sarah admonishes her husband. This same 12th century piyut, painted in the early 20th century by Mizrahi, morphs in the 1990`s into the song “The binder, the bound and the Altar,” by Ehud Manor and Meir Banai. The pious submission in the piyut and the painting become a modern song of outrage/protest:

And whenever the razor is drawn
I will say, Please, Lord, Remember

Lord of the Universe, don`t forget

THE BINDER, THE BOUND AND THE ALTAR.

Below, at center stage of Mizrahi`s painting, the altar scene is reenacted, programmed according to the Midrash from the sixth day of creation. This is no hastily built altar, but the venerable shrine first built by Adam and renewed by Noah at the sacred center of the universe.

9. AND THEY CAME TO THE PLACE THAT GOD HAD TOLD HIM; AND ABRAHAM BUILT THERE THE ALTAR which Adam had built, which had been destroyed by the flood, which Noah had again built and which had been destroyed by the generation of the division; HE ARRANGED THE WOOD ON IT, AND BOUND ISAAC HIS SON, AND LAID HIM ON THE ALTAR ON TOP OF THE WOOD.
(Targum Yonatan)

The ground cover is manicured, the actors formally set in place. Curious midrashic elements neutralize the inherent terror: Isaac’s hat on the branch behind Abraham (painted the color of the flowers on the other tree), his coat and shoes waiting to be donned again after the service, as the fire pot waits on the far side of the altar. Isaac and the angel wear identical outfits to indicate their special relationship. The column under Isaac’s head leads upward through the knife, held frozen, connecting heaven and earth.

In Mizrahi`s rendition, the special ram is not caught in the thicket but is part of the tree, as if his existence is part of the divine plan.

13. AND ABRAHAM LIFTED HIS EYES AND SAW, BEHOLD a certain RAM that was created in the twilight of the completion of the world, CAUGHT IN THE THICKET of a tree BY ITS HORNS; AND ABRAHAM WENT AND TOOK him AND OFFERED HIM UP
INSTEAD OF HIS SON.
(Targum Yonatan)

In the next tableau, we backtrack to the moment when father and son, grey beard leading black beard, leave their servants (captioned “Stay here with the ass”, v. 5). The servants are identified midrashically as Ishmael and Eliezer and contemporized as nargila smoking Turkish gendarmes. Thus, three historic “languages” (biblical, midrashic and the artist`s present) are effortlessly woven together.

Finally, a subsequent journey brings closure to this akedah, when Eliezer meets Rebecca, Isaac`s future bride. Two women frame Mizrahi`s account: Sarah sets the story in motion and Rebecca`s act of kindness echoes God`s saving hand in the akedah, guaranteeing continuity for Abraham`s seed.








More on Sarah — Sarah out of the closet

Independent of Mizrahi`s introduction of the hidden Sarah, contemporary artists are bringing Sarah out of the closet.

 

M. Ardon, Sarah, 1947

M. Ardon, Sarah, 1947

 

In 1947, Israeli artist Mordecai Ardon paints the worst scenario. Isaac lies dead at Sarah`s feet, his mother a large, grotesque weeping figure, screams the call of the shofar. Parallel and opposite the fallen Isaac, a fallen ladder of Jewish continuity conveys two dead ends: Jacob`s ladder, that will not be, and the train tracks to Auschwitz. The faceless mother and child echo the universal pieta motif, the mother holding her deceased child, whether in antiquity or in our times.

 

Woman with dead Warrior, Sardinia, 1000 BCE

Woman with dead Warrior
Sardinia, 1000 BCE

Glenna Goodacre,Vietnam Nurses Memorial, 1993

Glenna Goodacre,Vietnam Nurses Memorial, 1993

Some twenty years after Ardon`s Sarah, Israeli Yizhak Frankl brings Sarah out of the house, to a startling position under the altar. Is she the ultimate sacrifice or is she the angel?

Yitzhak Frankel, Akedat Yitzhak, 1960

Yitzhak Frankel, Akedat Yitzhak, 1960

 









Protest and Politics


George Segal, Sacrifice of Isaac, 1978

George Segal, Sacrifice of Isaac, 1978


The protest movement against the Vietnam War reached a climax in May 1970, when four student demonstrators were killed at Kent State University by the state militia. The University commissioned George Segal to create a memorial – but rejected his Akedah, having had in mind a sweet young thing placing a rose in the muzzle of a gun. Princeton University subsequently acquired this akedah, in which a brutish father directs the knife against his draft age son. Proportionately, the son is bigger than his father, but on his knees; he could rise up and overpower the older man. Such is the power of the older generation to manipulate the younger.


George Segal, The Sacrifice of Isaac, 1973

George Segal, The Sacrifice of Isaac, 1973

In an earlier (1973) Akedah, Segal already shocked his audience; a less than majestic Abraham, your neighbor in jeans, overfed and under exercised, towers above an angelic child. Is he about to leap up and flee? Embrace his father? Note that the knife is turned away at the final moment. By chance (?), Segal`s work was first exhibited immediately before the Yom Kippur war, in the summer of 1973. It seems to be a recurring national theme: in Christian art throughout Europe you see the holy family and the crucifixion; in Jewish art, both in Israel and abroad, you see the akedah.

In fact, the akedah appears to be a central obsession of Israeli artists, writers, poets and thinkers. And while the akedah used to evoke images in the Israeli imagination of self-sacrifice for the sake of national redemption, it has become, mainly since 1967, the focus of protest against the seemingly unending demands on the young. As a result, several striking transformations have taken place in treatments of the akedah: in addition to the highlighting of Sarah, as in Ardon`s painting, the ram has turned into a symbol of these insatiable demands, as in many of Menashe Kadishman`s works:


M. Kadishman, The Binding of Isaac, 1982-85

M. Kadishman, The Binding of Isaac, 1982-85

The story has within itself the seeds of its own subversion


Article Sources:

Genesis Chapter 22
Some time afterward, God put Abraham to the test. He said to him, “Abraham,” and he answered, “Here I am.” 2 And He said, “Take your son, your favored one, Isaac, whom you love, and go to the land of Moriah, and offer him there as a burnt offering on one of the heights that I will point out to you.” 3 So early next morning, Abraham saddled his ass and took with him two of his servants and his son Isaac. He split the wood for the burnt offering, and he set out for the place of which God had told him. 4 On the third day Abraham looked up and saw the place from afar. 5 Then Abraham said to his servants, “You stay here with the ass. The boy and I will go up there; we will worship and we will return to you.”
6 Abraham took the wood for the burnt offering and put it on his son Isaac. He himself took the firestone and the knife; and the two walked off together. 7 Then Isaac said to his father Abraham, “Father!” And he answered, “Yes, my son.” And he said, “Here are the firestone and the wood; but where is the sheep for the burnt offering?” 8 And Abraham said, “God will see to the sheep for His burnt offering, my son.” And the two of them walked on together.
9 They arrived at the place of which God had told him. Abraham built an altar there; he laid out the wood; he bound his son Isaac; he laid him on the altar, on top of the wood. 10 And Abraham picked up the knife to slay his son. 11 Then an angel of the Lord called to him from heaven: “Abraham! Abraham!” And he answered, “Here I am.” 12 And he said, “Do not raise your hand against the boy, or do anything to him. For now I know that you fear God, since you have not withheld your son, your favored one, from Me.” 13 When Abraham looked up, his eye fell upon a ram, caught in the thicket by its horns. So Abraham went and took the ram and offered it up as a burnt offering in place of his son. 14 And Abraham named that site Adonai-yireh, whence the present saying, “On the mount of the Lord there is vision.”
15 The angel of the Lord called to Abraham a second time from heaven, 16 and said, “By Myself I swear, the Lord declares: Because you have done this and have not withheld your son, your favored one, 17 I will bestow My blessing upon you and make your descendants as numerous as the stars of heaven and the sands on the seashore; and your descendants shall seize the gates of their foes. 18 All the nations of the earth shall bless themselves by your descendants, because you have obeyed My command.” 19 Abraham then returned to his servants, and they departed together for Beer-sheba; and Abraham stayed in Beer-sheba.

Targum Pseudo-Jonathan to Genesis 22
AND IT WAS AFTER THESE THINGS when Isaac and Ishmael argued, that Ishmael said, It is right that I should inherit Father since I am his first born. But Isaac said, It is right for me to inherit Father because I am the son of Sarah his wife and you are the son of Hagar my mother's maid. Ishmael answered saying, I am more worthy than you because I was circumcised at age 13; if it had been my will to hold back I would not have risked my life to be circumcised. But you were circumcised when you were 8 days old; had you known what it was all about you would not have risked your life. Isaac replied, Today I am 36 years old. If the Holy One, blessed be He, were to ask for all my limbs I would not hold back. Immediately these words were heard before the Lord of the universe and immediately the word of THE LORD TESTED ABRAHAM AND SAID TO HIM, ABRAHAM! 2. AND HE SAID, HERE I AM. AND HE SAID, TAKE YOUR SON, THE ONLY ONE THAT YOU LOVE, ISAAC, AND GO TO THE LAND OF worship, AND OFFER HIM THERE AS A BURNT OFFERING ON ONE OF THE MOUNTAINS THAT I WILL TELL YOU. 3. AND ABRAHAM AROSE EARLY IN THE MORNING, SADDLED HIS ASS, TOOK TWO OF HIS YOUNG MEN, Eliezer and Ishmael, WITH HIM, AND ISAAC HIS SON, AND HE SPLIT chips and young shoots and fig and palm WOOD which are fit FOR THE BURNT OFFERING: AND HE ROSE AND WENT TO THE PLACE WHICH THE LORD HAD TOLD HIM. 4. ON THE THIRD DAY ABRAHAM LIFTED HIS EYES AND SAW the cloud of glory smoking on the mountain and he recognized it FROM AFAR. 5. AND ABRAHAM SAID TO THE YOUNG MEN, STAY HERE WITH THE ASS; I AND THE LAD WILL GO THAT FAR to test whether the joyful thing I was promised... "so shall your seed be” will be established; WE WILL WORSHIP the Lord of the universe AND WILL RETURN TO YOU. 6. AND ABRAHAM TOOK THE -WOOD OF THE BURNT OFFERING AND LAID IT UPON ISAAC HIS SON: AND HE TOOK IN HIS HAND THE FIRE AND THE KNIFE AND THE TWO OF THEM WENT TOGETHER (as one). 7. AND ISAAC SAID TO ABRAHAM HIS FATHER, Abba, AND HE SAID, HERE I AM, MY SON; AND HE SAID, HERE IS THE FIRE AND THE WOOD; WHERE IS THE LAMB FOR THE OFFERING? 8. AND ABRAHAM SAID, THE LORD will choose FOR HIMSELF THE LAMB FOR THE OFFERING, MY SON. AND THE TWO OF THEM WENT with a whole heart TOGETHER (as one). 9. AND THEY CAME TO THE PLACE THAT GOD HAD TOLD HIM; AND ABRAHAM BUILT THERE THE ALTAR which Adam had built, which had been destroyed by the flood, which Noah had again built and which had been destroyed by the generation of the division; HE ARRANGED THE WOOD ON IT, AND BOUND ISAAC HIS SON, AND LAID HIM ON THE ALTAR ON TOP OF THE WOOD. 10. AND ABRAHAM STRETCHED FORTH HIS HAND AND TOOK THE KNIFE TO SLAY HIS SON. Isaac answered and said to his father, Bind me well, lest I struggle in mortal agony, and be thrown into the pit of destruction, and there be found a blemish in your sacrifice. (Now) the eyes of Abraham looked at the eyes of Isaac; but the eyes of Isaac looked at the angels on high. Isaac saw them but Abraham did not. And the angels on high answered, Come, see these unique people in the world, one slaying and other being slain; the one who slays does not withhold and the one to be slain stretches out his neck. 11. AND AN ANGEL OF THE LORD CALLED TO HIM FROM THE HEAVENS AND SAID TO HIM, ABHAHAM! ABRAHAM! AND HE SAID, HERE I AM. 12. AND HE SAID TO HIM, DO NOT SEND OUT YOUR HAND TO THE LAD AND DON'T DO ANYTHING evil TO HIM BECAUSE NOW it is clear to me THAT YOU FEAR THE LORD AND YOU HAVE NOT WITHHELD YOUR SON, YOUR ONLY ONE, FROM ME. 13. AND ABRAHAM LIFTED HIS EYES AND SAW, BEHOLD a certain RAM that was created in the twilight of the completion of the world, CAUGHT IN THE THICKET of a tree BY ITS HORNS; AND ABRAHAM WENT AND TOOK him AND OFFERED HIM UP INSTEAD OF HIS SON. 14. AND ABRAHAM gave thanks and prayed there, IN THAT PLACE and said, When I prayed for your mercy O Lord, it was clear to you that there was no guile in my heart, and I turned to perform your decree with joy, so that when the children of Isaac my son come to a time of suffering, let this be a remembrance for them, and answer them and save them, that all the generations to come may say, ON THIS MOUNTAIN Abraham bound Isaac his son, and there the Shekina of THE LORD WAS REVEALED to him. 15. AND THE ANGEL OF THE LORD CALLED TO ABRAHAM A SECOND TIME FROM THE HEAVENS. 16. AND SAID by my word HAVE I SWORN, SAID THE LORD, BECAUSE YOU HAVE DONE THIS THING AND HAVE NOT WITHHELD YOUR SON, YOUR ONLY ONE. 17. THAT IN BLESSING I WILL BLESS YOU AND IN MULTIPLYING, I WILL MULTIPLY YOUR children LIKE THE STARS OF THE HEAVENS AND THE SAND ON THE SEASHORE, and your children WILL INHERIT cities in the presence of THEIR ENEMIES 18. AND ALL THE NATIONS OF THE EARTH WILL BE BLESSED BECAUSE of the merit of your son; because you accepted my words. 19. And the angels on high took Isaac and brought him to the school of Shem the Great and he was there for three years. The same day ABRAHAM RETURNED TO THE YOUNG MEN AND THEY AROSE AND WENT TOGETHER TO BEER SHEBA; AND ABRAHAM LIVED IN BEER SHEBA. 20. AND IT WAS AFTER THESE THINGS, after Abraham had bound Isaac, that Satan came and told Sarah that Abraham had killed Isaac. Sarah rose up and cried out and choked and died because of the anguish…

Quran, Sura 37
. Abraham prayed: My Lord, grant me righteous children. 101. We gave him good news of a good child. 102. When he grew enough to work with him, he (Abraham) said, "My son, I see in a dream that I am sacrificing you. What do you think?" He said, "O my father, do what you are commanded to do. You will find me, God willing, patient." 103. They both submitted, and he put his forehead down (to sacrifice him). 104. We called him: "O Abraham. 105. "Have you believed the vision?" We thus reward the righteous. 106. That was an exacting test indeed. 107. We made a concession for a great slaughter. 108. And we preserved his history for subsequent generations. 109. Peace be upon Abraham. 110. We thus reward the righteous. 111. He is one of our believing servants.

From I Evoke the Memory of my Fathers – R. Ephraim of Bonn
Begged Isaac: bind for me my hands and my feet
.Lest I be found wanting and profane the sacrifice
.I am afraid of panic, I am concerned to honor you
.My will is to honor you greatly

,When he heard this, [Abraham]
whose soul was linked to the boy's like a bracelet
bound him hand and foot as if he were a whole offering
He put fire on the altar, wood on the fire
And on it offered the burnt offering

Then did the father and the son embrace
Mercy and Truth met and kissed each other
Oh, my father, fill your mouth with praise
.For He doth bless the sacrifice

He made haste, he pinned him down with his knees
.He made his two arms strong
With steady hands he slaughtered him according to the rite
.Full right was the slaughter

Down upon him fell the resurrecting dew, and he revived
[The father] seized him to slaughter him once more
:Scripture bear witness! Well-grounded is the fact
And the Lord called Abraham, even a second time from heaven

From Now is the time for the gates of favor to open  - R.Yehuda ben Shemuel Abbas
Now is the time for the gates of favor to open
A day on which I spread my palms to G-d in prayer
Please G-d, remember in my favor on this day of admonition
The binder, the bound and the altar

As the last test of the ten given to him by G-d, he was asked
The son that was born to you by Sarah
Although your soul is intensely attached to him
Rise, offer him as a pure sacrifice
On a mountain from which in you will see glory shining
The binder, the bound and the altar

Abraham said to Sarah: Your beloved Isaac
Has grown up but has not studied how to serve G-d
Let me take him and teach him the laws that G-d wishes him to follow
She responded: Go, my master but do not travel too far
Abraham answered: allow your heart to trust  in G-d
The binder, the bound and the altar